Skip to content
Read • Question • ConnectAnthony’s notes & researchReturn with a new question
Anthony’s NotesA personal field guide
From the notebook

Meaning of "The Jewish State" - Einat Wilf

What do we mean when we call Israel ‘The Jewish State’ - YouTube

History

  • Hebrews, emerged from Abraham, went to Egypt, exodus to Israel
  • Israelites, Kingdom of Israel
  • Exiled by Babylonians
  • Brought back by Persians, establishing Kingdom of Judaism
  • Judea is the beginning of what people speak of
  • All languages, except English and French, acknowledge that the Jewish people are called something similar to “Judea”
  • Kingdom of Judea
    • Rebelling against empires, recently the Romans
    • Romans put an end to rebelling, raised the place to the ground
    • Exiles them
  • They have an expectations of returning
  • Exile lasts 2000 years
    • Developments during the time is two great civilizations from Judaic thinking
      • Law, equality before God, monotheistic
      • Christianity then Islam
  • Judeans converts; Would be many more if not
  • Christianity and Islam developed an adverse nature towards Jews
    • Jew as the other.
  • Modern idea introduced new ideas
    • No God
    • Enlightenment
    • Idea of the Nation; secular, introduced by French Revolution

Birth of Zionism

  • Napoleon
    • Individuals you shall have everything, but as a people nothing
    • Must be part of France and not a Jewish nation within it
    • First moment in history to set aside the tribal national people within it
    • Judaism is denigrated to role of religion
  • Judaism is not only a religion; its a tribe a nation
  • Many Jews loved this idea, left the ghettos and enclosed surroundings and when out into the world thinking “Ok were all equal”
    • Yet, New Ideologies on the rise during Herzl time
      • Hierarchy of races
  • One of world’s first nations
  • Living in the time for the right to self-determination, right for people to govern themselves
  • People are freeing themselves from empires
  • The Jews wanted that right too

Zionism

  • Secular and atheist

  • Modern secular rebellion

  • Has worked for 1800-1900 years of praying to get back to Judea

    • Must do it themselves
  • Herzl thinks of Jewish like a secular national republic, not just for Jews

  • Many live like Jewish atheists: National, tribal, but not religious

  • Religious Zionism

    • One of most powerful in Israel today
    • God works in mysterious ways, choose atheists do to his work
    • Bringing people back to Holy Land
    • Powerful in last 40 years since 67 and 73 war.
    • Jewish orthodoxy is a reaction to modernity
    • Opposition to Israel is theological
  • Jews have no Pope or church, so how do they decide how to be Jewish? They argue and debate how to be Jewish in the modern area.

  • Definition: One state in the world where you can argue what it means to be the Jewish state.

  • Judaism has a lot of texts and traditions and a whole lot of people that said a lot of things for thousands of years. You can literally pick and choose whatever you want to justify.

  • Makes Israel a strong democracy