Skip to content
Read • Question • ConnectAnthony’s notes & researchReturn with a new question
Anthony’s NotesA personal field guide
From the notebook

Colonialism - A Moral Reckoning - Nigel Biggar

  • I’ve noticed that you know Empire has been a feature of human history since almost the dawn of time people with non-white skins Arabs Indians Comanche and others were doing Empire long before Europeans did it why the obsession with the European Empires why why the fixation on British Empire and I interpret it as being an assault on the record of the West.

  • British Empire Rise

    • 1600s
      • Trade between England and India
      • Bases in India
      • Go West across Atlantic
        • Harass Spanish shipping since it was harassing English shipping
        • Hunting for Gold, not necessarily land
    • 19th Century
      • Rule East Africa
        • Suppress Arab slave trade
      • End of wars by treaty to rule land
      • Sometimes racial arrogance
      • Mixture of virtue and vice; Imperial venture is no different
    • Negatives
      • 150 years of slave trade and slavery
        • 1650-1807
      • Racial arrogance
      • Abrupt disruption of social, cultural and economic lives of Native peoples in North America, Australia and Africa
        • Cultural, scientific gap between 19th Century Europeans and others was vast
        • Impact of modernity, which would happen one way or another, was severe
      • Disease
        • European domesticated animals helped Europeans become immune to many diseases
        • Other people also spread it
          • Indonesian fisherman to Northern Australia
        • Was NOT spread deliberately
    • No systematic genocide
    • Strove to moderate impact of settlers on natives
      • Especially during 1800s
    • Restrained settler violence
    • Equal Justice
    • India
      • British created it
      • Sadly divided into India/Pakistan due to religious tension
      • Common language/market/state
      • Democracy
      • Vigor of economy is abandonment of socialist policies
    • Comparisons between other Colonizers
      • British more reluctant to let native elites to top of government
        • French were better
      • British liberal principle that colonies must become increasing more independent
        • Learn from American Revolution
        • Can’t keep tight control of far colonies
        • Canada 1860
        • New Zealand
        • South Africa
        • India
        • Relaxing commonwealth of nations
        • French wanted to integrate colonies into France
    • Violence
      • It was a rough time
      • Belgium cruel to African in the Congo
      • German Southwest Africa
        • Genocide
      • Japanese
        • 100,000s killed in China
    • British abolition of slavery
      • 1800s-> second half of life
        • Brazil
        • Africa
        • India
        • Malaysia
        • 1804 - took over South Africa from Dutch and stopped the slavery Dutch were getting from Malaysia
    • Misc/Documents/Colonialism - A Moral Reckoning - Nigel Biggar-20240606130035418.webp
  • Was Colonialism Racist?

    • Racism is common
    • Britain didn’t invent it
    • Making discriminate judgements about another culture is not racist.
      • Scientifically, technologically, or morally inferior
    • You can say about your own race and people compared to 1000 years ago, so you can do it with other peoples as well
    • Provided you discriminate
    • Christian view
      • Fueled the movements to abolish slavery
      • Everyone equal under God