Skip to content
Read • Question • ConnectAnthony’s notes & researchReturn with a new question
Anthony’s NotesA personal field guide
From the notebook

Boy Crisis - Toxic Influences

⚠️ Toxic Influences

⬅️ Hub: Boy Crisis MOC

The Tate-shaped hole: who fills the vacuum when mentors disappear.

Toxic Influences filling the gap

  • The Internet as Surrogate Father: Boys often search YouTube or Reddit for life advice—dating, fitness, meaning—and are then pulled into misogynistic, reactionary ideologies that offer certainty, validation, and blame (e.g., “you’re failing because of women/feminism”).
  • The Importance of Alternative Narratives: Panelists stressed that if society doesn’t provide boys with healthy narratives, toxic influencers will.

Of Boys and Men _ Why the Modern Male Is S - Reeves, Richard copy, p.163 (file not included in this release)

Daniel Schwammenthal, director of the American Jewish Committee’s Transatlantic Institute, says, “The iron rule of politics is that if there are real problems in society and responsible parties don’t deal with them, the irresponsible parties will jump on them.”44

⚠️ Vulnerability to Negative Influence

  • As a result of these societal dislocations, many boys feel alienated, disoriented, and purposeless, which makes them susceptible to toxic online subcultures.
  • Reeves describes how disenfranchised boys are drawn into the “manosphere”—a mix of online communities that range from pickup artists and incels to MGTOWs (Men Going Their Own Way). These groups offer:
    • A false sense of clarity about masculinity.
    • Manipulative ideologies that often spiral into misogyny and conspiracy thinking.
    • A misleading narrative that men are victims of a feminist-controlled society​.

“The boys who are lost, who fall through the cracks of our society’s stereotypes and straight into the arms of the communities ready to recruit them… greedy to indoctrinate them with fears of threats to their manhood.” — Laura Bates, quoted by Reeves​.

🔁 Cycle of Disadvantage and Exploitation

  • The economic and social isolation experienced by boys—especially from low-income or broken families—creates a cycle:
    • Economic instability → Identity crisis → Seeking meaning → Radicalization potential.
    • As Reeves notes, these young men are “ripe for exploitation” by anyone offering a sense of purpose, however destructive.

“Underneath it all is a deep well of confusion and disorientation, which, as always, somebody is willing to exploit.”​

Of Boys and Men _ Why the Modern Male Is S - Reeves, Richard copy, p.66 (file not included in this release)

integrated into a community through a role in a family, spanning generations into the past and future, will be more consistently and durably tied to the social order than a man responding chiefly to a charismatic leader, a demagogue, or a grandiose ideology of patriotism.” That’s George Gilder writing in 1973.