Back to Ethics · Metaethics · Normative Ethics · Debates and Religion
Source studies and arguments about God, morality, power, and public justification. The active learning and practice notes remain in the Debate project; this map connects them to the philosophy inventory.
Which claim? Why only God? What reasons? Why better?
Framing questions from Does Morality Require Religion - Master.
Current learning and the strongest challenge
- Does Morality Require Religion - Master — the active map and recorded progress; the framework remains provisional.
- Morality and Religion - Andrew Wilson Challenge — the source-located opposition and corrections to earlier responses.
- REF - Objective Morality and God — supporting arguments, objections, and source boundaries.
- Morality and Religion - Learning Path — the bounded learning sequence.
- Morality and Religion - Move Drill — retrieve the response aloud before checking it.
Wilson, Dyer, and other debate audits
- Analysis of Andrew Wilson Debate (Moral Language) — the larger conceptual inventory and proposed replies.
- Analysis of Andrew Wilson Debate (Moral Language) research list — the original short research checklist.
- Parker vs Jay Dyer on Subjectivity — the existing debate capture on subjectivity and divine grounding.
- Hume, Reid, and Locke - Destiny v Asmongold Philosophy Audit — source and historical checks on common sense, progress, rights, and consent.
- atheist_vs_theist_objective_morality_dialogue_tree (file not included in this release) — the preserved visual argument inventory and link to the revised live map.
Secular accounts and the power objection
- Secular Morality — the main research note, with a newer scope warning and notebook connections.
- Secular Morality 1 — a separate older overview retained intact; not silently merged into the main research note.
- Can Atheism and Reason Ground Morality? — the proposed secular routes and their difficulties.
- Force Doctrine — the collected arguments about force, authority, and rights.
- Against "Force Doctrine" — the preserved Philip D. Bunn article and response section.
- Countering Advantage of the Stronger — the non-theistic response toolkit.
- Performative Morality — rhetoric, consistency, and public moral claims.
Cross-vault connections
Lance Bush — main note and journal pages · Trent Horn - Objective Morality Debate Audit · Andrew Wilson - Political Ideology, Philosophical Foundations, and Program · Metaethics
Auto-index
Notes in this topic
60.9.3.2 Ethics (file not included in this release)